Lawsuit Against Realtor Over Second Hand Smoke Disclosure Raises A Stink

Looks like Realtors may have to knock on the neighbors door to see if anyone smokes?? This is nuts!

Lawsuit over second hand smoke

Yesterday the Boston Globe reported on a controversial lawsuit by a Alyssa Burrage, a condominium buyer, against a realtor over the disclosure of second hand smoke emitting from downstairs neighbors. Click for the story: Suit Over Second Hand Smoke Targets Real Estate Broker. As the hundreds of comments to the story indicates, this lawsuit raises a host of legal and public policy issues. I’ll focus on the legal issues.

Under Massachusetts consumer protection regulations governing real estate brokers, a broker must disclose to a buyer “any fact, the disclosure of which may have influenced the buyer or prospective buyer not to enter into the transaction.”  This is somewhat of a subjective standard; what may matter to one buyer may not matter to another. If a broker is asked a direct question about the property, she must answer truthfully, accurately, and completely to the best of her knowledge. Further, a broker cannot actively avoid discovering the details of a suspected problem or tell half-truths.

With that legal backdrop, let’s review the facts of this case. Ms. Burrage, who suffers from asthma, claimed that her broker failed to disclose the existence of the heavy smokers downstairs—despite the fact that she admittedly smelled “the unmistakable stench” of cigarette smoke at several visits to the unit. The broker – who worked for the same company as the listing broker (which may raise some thorny conflict of interest/agency issues) – assured her that the smell would dissipate once she painted and renovated the unit, the suit claims. Ms. Burrage claims that she wouldn’t have purchased the unit in the first place if she had known about the smoke problem.

The case boils down to the appropriate scope of a broker’s duty to disclose potentially adverse property conditions, not only within the property itself, but off-site. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has held that off-site physical conditions may require disclosure if the conditions are “unknown and not readily observable by the buyer [and] if the existence of those conditions is of sufficient materiality to affect the habitability, use, or enjoyment of the property and, therefore, render the property substantially less desirable or valuable to the objectively reasonable buyer.”

This case has all the makings of a very slippery — and dangerous — slope for real estate brokers. If Ms. Burrage’s claim is accepted, realtors would be conceivably obligated to investigate every neighbor to determine whether their smoking (or other bad habits) will negatively affect the particular buyer’s use or enjoyment of the property. That’s patently unrealistic. Where then does the law draw the line? If it’s not smoking, it’s smelly food preparation (don’t laugh, I’ve dealt with those cases), marijuana smoking, loud parties, floor stomping, or other “noxious” behaviors. Buyers of condominiums have to accept that they aren’t buying into a pristine, sanitary bubble.

I’m not unsympathetic to Ms. Burrage’s plight. I’m not a smoker, and I cannot stand the smell of cigarette smoke. But to me, this is really a neighbor-to-neighbor issue. The realtor should have no liability in this type of case.

A very interesting case indeed…

 

 

 facebook icontwitter

  

//

For Your Ultimate and Complete home search go to http://FindSouthCoastHomes.com

 

Google

Looking for a Realtor that knows the market, understands your concerns, and will help you gettop dollar for your home? Call me today. ask about my "Easy Exit" Listing Guarantee.

 

Lori Lincoln
Keller Williams Realty- Taunton area
http://findsouthcoasthomes.com
lorilincoln@kw.com
508-878-0917
 

  Search Thousands of Homes for Sale -Ultimate Taunton MA Information and Home Search 

Find out what your home value is-- No obligation and can be given online- 

Find my Taunton Area Home Value NOW!

 Get the latest Taunton Area real estate news and housing trends for Greater Taunton MA, http://twitter.com/mahomesforsale    http://tauntonarea.housingtrendsnewsletter.com

Comment balloon 4 commentsLori Lincoln Team • February 17 2010 07:30AM
Lawsuit Against Realtor Over Second Hand Smoke Disclosure Raises A…
share
Looks like Realtors may have to knock on the neighbors door to see if anyone smokes?? This is nuts! Yesterday the Boston Globe reported on a controversial lawsuit by a Alyssa Burrage, a condominium buyer, against a realtor over the… more
Owning a home is AWESOME - but it should not own you!
share
Michelle Gordon- I couldn't have said it better myself. Buyers may be approved for a higher monthly payment than what they feel they can afford. Buyers.. listen to the inner voice before you decide to over extend! I was reading an article that one… more
Be from the Country.. Dighton Massachusetts Real Estate Not a short…
share
more
How is a Loss Really A Gain??? Taunton, Dighton, Lakeville, Rehoboth…
share
How is a Loss Really a Gain??? Taunton, Dighton, Lakeville, Rehoboth Massachusetts Real Estate How is a loss really a gain? The graph below illustrates how a loss on the sale of a home today can be made up by a gain on a higher priced… more